EVERY OBJECTION ANSWERED

Frequently asked questions.

What would change? What would it cost? Read the answers and the facts behind them. Open a question to see more.

At a glance

Ask the hard questions

  1. Ask a question
  2. Read the facts
  3. Make up your mind

Who controls bylaw enforcement?

The committee can choose which files come first. It can direct staff to close a file. Staff handle notices and reviews. A separate hearing officer rules on ticket disputes. Read who has each power and the law behind it. Sources: Read Denman's current framework and primary sources

Would a town raise our taxes?

We need the costs for Denman. The study must show taxes, grants, debt and each service a town would run. Bowen's bills do not tell us what our bills would be. Put a clear plan to a local vote.

Read the cost evidence →

Who would look after our roads?

BC runs Denman's roads now. The study must set out who would own, fix and pay for them under a town. Any change needs clear terms with BC. We want the cost and the service plan before we vote.

See the steps to a town →

What about the ferry?

BC Ferries runs the route. A town council would not run the ferry. We want an elected local body to press our case on service, plans and costs. Better service would still depend on those who run and fund the route.

Read who does what →

Could a town help with power cuts?

BC Hydro runs the power system. We want local plans for storms, backup power and help when the lights go out. A town study should show what the council could do, what others already do and how each choice would be paid for.

Read the short case →

What about our wells?

Most homes use wells. A town would not take over your well just by being formed. We want sound water studies and clear plans for safe use. Land-use rules must fit the water we have and protect the places where rain soaks in.

Read Denman's water record →

What about internet and cell service?

Providers still run the networks. A town could make the island's case for better service. The study should map the gaps, set out who can act and show the costs. Use the work that island volunteers have already done.

Read the service choices →

What happens to waste, reuse and the Free Store?

A town does not gain our local groups' land or work just by being formed. We value reuse and the people who make it work. The study must show which waste services would change, which would stay and who would pay.

See the local service map →

How could a town help with homes?

A council could set local land-use rules within the law. We want more homes of more kinds, with water and septic plans that work. Land, loans and build costs still matter. Compare the rules and the real cost of each choice.

Read the housing evidence →

Would a town mean too much growth?

A town is a way to make local choices. It does not remove BC's laws or make each project pass. We want clear plans for homes, water, farms and nature, with elected people we can hold to account.

Read the powers and steps →

What happens to shellfish farms?

BC, Canada and the Trust have different powers in Baynes Sound. A town would not take all of those powers. We want a clear local voice and a plan that shows who makes each choice.

See who has which powers →

What happens to our local groups?

Our local groups own and run much of island life. A town would not gain their land, buildings or work just by being formed. Any change needs a clear agreement with the group. Build on their work and respect their choices.

Read the case for local choice →

Would BC's land and nature rules still apply?

Yes. A town still has to follow the law. Under current law, a new Denman town would be in the Trust area and its community plan would need Trust approval. Other farm, water and land rules also apply.

Read the legal path →

Why not end the Islands Trust?

We want a town for Denman. There is also a separate campaign asking BC to end the Trust. These are two different decisions. You can support one, both or neither. Read the words of each petition before you sign.

Read the separate abolition case →

Why not change the Trust from within?

We want a council elected to serve Denman as a whole. Changes within the Trust could still be useful. They do not by themselves give Denman a town council. Read our case and weigh the choices.

Read why we want a council →

What about the K'ómoks Nation?

The K'ómoks Nation has its own rights, voice and treaty process. A town study must work with the Nation and set out how those rights affect each choice. The petition supports that work. Read the Nation's own words to learn its views.

Follow the original sources →

Why start now?

Homes, work, water and costs all shape our future. We want people who live here to have a stronger say. Start the study so Denman can choose with clear facts.

Read the short case →

How long would it take?

There is no fixed date for a Denman town. BC must agree to the next steps. A study, public work and a vote all take time. We want a clear process with public dates and costs.

See each step →

What if people vote no?

Then that plan does not go ahead on the basis of that vote. The study would still give Denman facts about powers, costs and choices. We want a fair vote on a clear plan.

Read the path to a vote →

Does Tony have a personal land-use interest?

Yes. Tony Aly runs this site and lives at Camp Denman, a property with long-running land-use disputes with the Trust. That interest is declared so you can weigh the case. Check each claim against its source.

Read the full disclosure →

Who would pay for the study?

BC can fund some local government studies. Funding is a choice for BC, not an automatic grant. We want a clear scope, a public budget and a funding decision before work starts. The full cost for Denman is not yet set.

Read the funding and process questions →

Spread the word

Save imageEmailSMSWhatsAppFacebookXBlueskyThreadsRedditTelegramLinkedIn
Sign the petition →