Public record · denmantown.org

Petition revision history

We corrected a mistake. Version 1 asked for a Restructure Study toward a municipality “within the Islands Trust,” while surrounding copy said we were not arguing for abolition. That surrounding claim was wrong. Version 2 still asks for a town, explains the current-law constraint, and says plainly that this is not a promise to keep the Trust. Version 3 corrects one legal-status phrase: the K’ómoks Treaty is in a ratification and implementation process, not simply “currently being implemented.”

We also found that version 1 appeared in two different public renderings: a shorter statement on the sign page and a longer petition on the homepage and PDF. The database recorded only “version 1,” not the page a signer used. Both renderings are preserved below; we will not pretend to know which one every individual saw.

Version 3 — current

Adopted 2026-08-24. Corrected the K’ómoks Treaty status phrase without changing the request for a Restructure Study.

  • Replaced ‘Treaty currently being implemented’ with ‘Treaty ratification and implementation process.’
  • Preserved every version-2 signature against the exact wording that signer confirmed.
  • Made no change to the requested study, municipal question, or two-petition doctrine.

Exact petition text

To the Honourable Minister of Housing and Municipal Affairs of the Province of British Columbia, and to all Members of the Legislative Assembly of British Columbia. We, the undersigned Denman Island residents, qualifying non-resident property electors, and connected supporters, respectfully petition the Government of British Columbia to commission a Restructure Study under the Local Government Act for the purpose of evaluating the incorporation of Denman Island as a self-governing municipality. Under current law, any new municipality whose area lies entirely in the Islands Trust area must be incorporated as an island municipality (Local Government Act s. 6). That is why a study commissioned today would use the Bowen Island Municipality model. We want a town whether or not the Islands Trust continues. This petition is not a promise to keep the Trust, and it is not a substitute for the separate petition asking the Province to abolish it. Property ownership alone does not establish elector eligibility. We make this request on the following grounds: — Denman Island has grown by 19.4 percent between the 2016 and 2021 censuses — roughly two and a half times the BC provincial average growth rate over the same period; — Denman Island is currently governed by a fragmented patchwork of overlapping authorities including the Islands Trust, the Comox Valley Regional District, the BC Ministry of Transportation and Infrastructure, BC Ferries, and separate community organizations and local service bodies, none of which is directly elected by and accountable to Denman residents as a single coherent local government; — The Islands Trust Council has itself, in 2022 and again in 2024, formally requested a comprehensive provincial review of the Islands Trust Act and its governance structures; — Bowen Island (1999) and the Okanagan Falls process approved by referendum in 2025 provide useful BC examples of restructure studies and local incorporation; Okanagan Falls is scheduled to incorporate formally on November 6, 2026; — A Restructure Study is the lawful, evidence-based first step in this process, providing residents and the Province with the financial, demographic, and governance information necessary to make an informed decision at a referendum. — Signing this petition supports a town for Denman. It does not require the signer to support abolition, and it does not forbid it. We therefore respectfully request that the Province commission a formal Restructure Study for Denman Island, with funding from the Restructure Planning Grant program of the Ministry of Housing and Municipal Affairs, and conducted by an independent consultant in collaboration with Denman residents, the Comox Valley Regional District, the Islands Trust, and — in recognition of the K’ómoks Treaty ratification and implementation process — the K’ómoks First Nation, with appropriate acknowledgement of the Pentlatch People whose traditional territory includes Denman Island. We are prepared to do the work alongside you. We are asking only for the chance to ask ourselves the question.

Version 2

Adopted 2026-08-23. Established one exact petition text and clarified that asking for a town does not promise to preserve the Islands Trust.

  • Kept the request for a provincially commissioned Restructure Study.
  • Explained the current-law island-municipality constraint.
  • Stated that the town and abolition petitions are separate decisions.
  • Made the homepage, sign flow, confirmation page, correction email, history, and PDF use the same full text.

Exact petition text

To the Honourable Minister of Housing and Municipal Affairs of the Province of British Columbia, and to all Members of the Legislative Assembly of British Columbia. We, the undersigned Denman Island residents, qualifying non-resident property electors, and connected supporters, respectfully petition the Government of British Columbia to commission a Restructure Study under the Local Government Act for the purpose of evaluating the incorporation of Denman Island as a self-governing municipality. Under current law, any new municipality whose area lies entirely in the Islands Trust area must be incorporated as an island municipality (Local Government Act s. 6). That is why a study commissioned today would use the Bowen Island Municipality model. We want a town whether or not the Islands Trust continues. This petition is not a promise to keep the Trust, and it is not a substitute for the separate petition asking the Province to abolish it. Property ownership alone does not establish elector eligibility. We make this request on the following grounds: — Denman Island has grown by 19.4 percent between the 2016 and 2021 censuses — roughly two and a half times the BC provincial average growth rate over the same period; — Denman Island is currently governed by a fragmented patchwork of overlapping authorities including the Islands Trust, the Comox Valley Regional District, the BC Ministry of Transportation and Infrastructure, BC Ferries, and separate community organizations and local service bodies, none of which is directly elected by and accountable to Denman residents as a single coherent local government; — The Islands Trust Council has itself, in 2022 and again in 2024, formally requested a comprehensive provincial review of the Islands Trust Act and its governance structures; — Bowen Island (1999) and the Okanagan Falls process approved by referendum in 2025 provide useful BC examples of restructure studies and local incorporation; Okanagan Falls is scheduled to incorporate formally on November 6, 2026; — A Restructure Study is the lawful, evidence-based first step in this process, providing residents and the Province with the financial, demographic, and governance information necessary to make an informed decision at a referendum. — Signing this petition supports a town for Denman. It does not require the signer to support abolition, and it does not forbid it. We therefore respectfully request that the Province commission a formal Restructure Study for Denman Island, with funding from the Restructure Planning Grant program of the Ministry of Housing and Municipal Affairs, and conducted by an independent consultant in collaboration with Denman residents, the Comox Valley Regional District, the Islands Trust, and — in recognition of the K’ómoks Treaty currently being implemented — the K’ómoks First Nation, with appropriate acknowledgement of the Pentlatch People whose traditional territory includes Denman Island. We are prepared to do the work alongside you. We are asking only for the chance to ask ourselves the question.

Version 1

Adopted before 2026-08-23 (exact first-publication date not recorded). The original app published two version-1 renderings while recording only one version number.

  • The short rendering below appeared on /sign.
  • The longer rendering below appeared on the homepage and in the PDF.
  • Because the database did not record the entry surface, the project cannot claim which rendering an individual signer saw.

Short /sign rendering

We, the undersigned, residents and supporters of Denman Island, British Columbia, ask the Province of British Columbia to commission an independent Restructure Study under the Local Government Act for Denman Island as an island municipality within the Islands Trust area, informed by Bowen Island Municipality (1999) and the Okanagan Falls incorporation process approved by referendum in 2025, with formal incorporation scheduled for November 6, 2026. We do so because Denman is presently governed by fourteen separate bodies, none of which is a single elected council answerable to Denman residents. We do so because the patchwork has produced measurable failures — a Denman Green housing project first proposed in 2013 and declared shovel-ready in 2024, with no completed homes yet; a food bank with a growing caseload; aging infrastructure decisions made off-island; recurring power outages on lines no local body has standing to renegotiate. And we do so because the institutional architecture required to be a real partner to the K'ómoks Nation under its modern treaty does not yet exist on the Denman side of the table. Signing this petition is a request for a study, not a vote on incorporation. Denman residents will decide that question, by referendum, on a fair record.

Longer homepage/PDF rendering

To the Honourable Minister of Housing and Municipal Affairs of the Province of British Columbia, and to all Members of the Legislative Assembly of British Columbia. We, the undersigned Denman Island residents, qualifying non-resident property electors, and connected supporters, respectfully petition the Government of British Columbia to commission a Restructure Study under the Local Government Act for the purpose of evaluating the incorporation of Denman Island as a self-governing municipality within the Islands Trust, informed by the Bowen Island Municipality model. Property ownership alone does not establish elector eligibility. We make this request on the following grounds: — Denman Island has grown by 19.4 percent between the 2016 and 2021 censuses — roughly two and a half times the BC provincial average growth rate over the same period; — Denman Island is currently governed by a fragmented patchwork of overlapping authorities including the Islands Trust, the Comox Valley Regional District, the BC Ministry of Transportation and Infrastructure, BC Ferries, and separate community organizations and local service bodies, none of which is directly elected by and accountable to Denman residents as a single coherent local government; — The Islands Trust Council has itself, in 2022 and again in 2024, formally requested a comprehensive provincial review of the Islands Trust Act and its governance structures; — Bowen Island (1999) and the Okanagan Falls process approved by referendum in 2025 provide useful BC examples of restructure studies and local incorporation; Okanagan Falls is scheduled to incorporate formally on November 6, 2026; — A Restructure Study is the lawful, evidence-based first step in this process, providing residents and the Province with the financial, demographic, and governance information necessary to make an informed decision at a referendum. We therefore respectfully request that the Province commission a formal Restructure Study for Denman Island, with funding from the Restructure Planning Grant program of the Ministry of Housing and Municipal Affairs, and conducted by an independent consultant in collaboration with Denman residents, the Comox Valley Regional District, the Islands Trust, and — in recognition of the K’ómoks Treaty currently being implemented — the K’ómoks First Nation, with appropriate acknowledgement of the Pentlatch People whose traditional territory includes Denman Island. We are prepared to do the work alongside you. We are asking only for the chance to ask ourselves the question.

Ownership and relevant interest

Denman Town is a private project maintained by Tony Aly, who lives at Camp Denman, a property with longstanding land-use disputes with the Islands Trust. That interest is disclosed because readers should weigh it. The project is not an official government or locally endorsed initiative.

Return to the petition →